I’ve written about ten different manifestos for this trip, at this point. The problem with writing ten manifestos is that usually, as a rule, you’re only permitted one manifesto per thing. The communists only got the one, and so it only seems fair that I should have the same. So, this morning I woke up and wrote another. About halfway through, I realized that the point of this trip, of anything as grandiose as this, is perpetual redefinition. The joy of doubting, doubling down, and searching for meaning. I think there will be new reasons to do this every day spent out on the water. My goal is to capture those reasons and in the end, have an answer. Or, as many answers as there were days.
This morning, my answer went something like this:
When the Luddites smashed the textile machines two centuries ago, they were protecting their jobs and the quality of their work, but also rejecting the premise of the industrial age—that progress is not only desirable, but inevitable, and that this is what progress looks like. When the early historians, economists, and anthropologists of the modern age described their societies, they conveniently placed them at the end of a long, Darwinian chain of human evolution. The closer a society is with the natural world, the more primitive. As it divorces itself from its base nature, and moves closer to, then, the smog-clogged industrial cities of Europe, and now, the clean hydro-powered utopias of computation, it progresses. Now, thank god, same-day-delivery can bring you a packet of craft singles surrounded by, and tasting of, styrofoam. More cynical and insidious than the contents of progress, which have certainly brought about all sorts of lovely things, is how it is sold to us as inevitable. All of this was inevitable, apparently. This understanding of the world and our history has not faded. It is living and breathing, running laps around us as we speak. Inevitability is a lie, an ill-defined, opaque and well-funded lie. The Luddites knew this, as do others.
This morning I read an interview with Terence Tao, one of the world’s most brilliant mathematicians. The interview concerned the recent proofs by Open AI of the Navier-Stokes problem, one of the seven Millennium Prize problems. This proof, and the many smaller proofs released by the company drove a train through the world of mathematics. Careers were smashed, but so were the intangible realities of these thinkers relationships with their work.
“Have you ever had an epiphany? When the whole room just makes sense?”
That is what a Berkley mathematician asked the interviewer, in response to a question about the future of their field. It was said almost mournfully. The epiphany is gone. It took a swarm of 10,000 AI agents 88 hours to complete that proof. It cost somewhere between 6 million and 22 million dollars. They have the power and money to do that, now. That problem was being worked on by human beings for the last century. And now, we’ve built tools that can solve it. But the epiphany is gone. We have the answer, but nobody solved it. What is lost when you remove the human being from the process of knowledge? What is lost when you isolate knowledge from a setting, a time, a place, a geography? That is at the heart of why I want to spend seven months in a canoe.
In the final class of my degree we were offered several books to choose from. Jessica told us to “read it and talk about it in groups, then come back to me.” My group read As We Have Always Done, by Leanne Betasamosake Simpson, a Nishnabeg scholar from the great lakes region. The entire premise of the book is this thuddingly obvious and completely elusive idea of knowledge. She tells many stories of how she, walking the worlds between the academy and her reserve lands, has learned her lessons. In short, she arrives at the conclusion that knowledge is contained in the doing, by people, in places. This is a very simple and radical idea. Knowledge can absolutely exist theoretically and decoupled from place—Terence Tao spends almost all of his time in this theoretical place. However, so much of what we know cannot be known unless lived. These lessons, in their inherently experiential nature, cannot be taken-up in an inspired reading of the right words. They take time to become true. Time and effort. This is beautiful, because it frees us from the acceleration of AI, and the narrative of inevitability. There are some things, very important things, that can only be lived at the pace at which we live.
The Luddites did not go quietly. It was only when the bosses and their thugs began executing them, with the help of British soldiers, that the factories could turn on—That the “inevitable” could continue.
And so, we return to inevitability. Inevitability is a lie, an ill-defined, opaque and well-funded lie. Its the shoulder shrug so common when interviewing AI CEOs about their responsibility or the future of their products. As if to say: “It’s out of my hands. It’s inevitable.” It disempowers all political speech and most terrifyingly, our political imaginations. What is possible is narrowed to one, singular, fixed point in a world of inevitability. That point is the future, and it is only a projection of now. Gratefully, these are fictions and we do not live in an inevitable world. For me, I remind myself of this through experimenting with the absurd and the playful. Enchanted Broccoli forest, the qathet Canoe Race. Absurdity, surrealism, these are good responses to a politics of inevitability. The Luddites remind us of other responses, ones that involve more fire and axes. Perhaps for another time. For now, we indulge in the absurd and the difficult, and the uncomfortable because it is the only way, not only to learn, it simply is the only way. Today, that is why we will canoe across Canada. I look forward to figuring out tomorrow.